‘This Is the City of Stonewall:’ NYC Launches Billboard War in Florida Over ‘Don’t Say Gay’ Law

April 5, 2022

New York City, where the Stonewall Inn riots ignited what many consider to be the birth of the modern LGBTQ+ rights movement, has long voiced its support for that community. Now it wants its message heard in one place, especially: Florida.

Starting Monday, Mayor Eric Adams is wallpapering the Sunshine State with digital billboards espousing New York City’s vociferous opposition to the so-called “Don’t Say Gay” bill that Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis signed into law, he said Monday.

The GOP legislation, which has drawn intense national scrutiny, bars instruction on sexual orientation and gender identity in kindergarten through third grade, which the mayor called a “targeted attack on the LGBTQ+ population.”

The billboards, Adams said from City Hall, will be up for eight weeks in five major Florida markets, including Fort Lauderdale, Jacksonville, Orlando, Tampa and West Palm Beach, and are expected to deliver an estimated 5 million impressions.

“This is the city of Stonewall. This is the city where we are proud to talk about how you can live in a comfortable setting and not be harassed, not be abused — not only as adults but also as young people,” Adams said.

The campaign started Monday and runs through May 29. Creative content was donated by WPP agencies including VMLY&R, BCW, H+K Strategies and Kinetic, Adams said. Kinetic secured the ad space.

“People say a lot of ridiculous things in New York. ‘Don’t Say Gay’ isn’t one of them,” one reads. Another says, “When other states show their true colors. We show ours.”

The message is simple — and directed at Florida’s LGBTQ community, Adams said: “Listen, hey, we want you in New York.” Come here where you can be you.

The Democrat forcefully denounced the Florida law, calling it “political showmanship” and accusing DeSantis’ administration and GOP supporters of “attempting to demonize a particular group or community.

Adams called that “unacceptable” and said the city plans to loudly voice its support in the other direction. He acknowledged everyone’s right to self-identification, saying that at some times, it can be a literal matter of life and death.

“Other people like to hide their color,” Adams said. “We like to show our color and that’s the rainbow that’s representative of this community.”

Although known as a supporter of LGBTQ rights during his political career including six years in New York’s state Senate, Adams angered LGBTQ activists earlier this year when he appointed three men who have taken anti-gay positions to posts.

“This is not a community that’s going to be silent,” Adams said when asked about the hires Monday. “If they see something they don’t like, they’ll let you know.”

“We can work through anything but we will never go to the days where we will publicly demonize a group, and that’s what’s happening now,” he added. “And so they voiced their concern about the hires that we made and we’re going to continue to move forward.”

New York state has seen more migration to Florida than from Florida in recent years. In the last three years of the 2010s, more than 60,000 New Yorkers moved to Florida each year, on average. By contrast, during the same period, fewer than 24,000 Floridians moved to New York state, according to federal figures.

Now that the Parental Rights in Education bill (also referred to as the “Don’t Say Gay” bill) is law in Florida, LGBTQ groups plan to fight it in the courts. Critics have said the law is worded so broadly that it could have a chilling effect on teachers and cause them to dismiss LGBTQ subjects entirely. We hear from Michael Womack, communications manager at Equality Florida, an organization preparing to sue the state government over the bill.
The law has catapulted Florida and DeSantis, a potential 2024 Republican presidential candidate, to the forefront of the country’s culture wars. Republicans say parents should broach these subjects with children. Critics argue that the true intent of the law is to marginalize LGBTQ people and their families.

Advocates have already filed suit in the state over it and more challenges are likely.

The lawsuit claims the legislation deliberately uses broad terms and invites arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement, empowering parents to be roving censors who can sue school boards for damages based on any perceived violation.

Specifically, it states: “Classroom instruction by school personnel or third parties on sexual orientation or gender identity may not occur in kindergarten through grade 3 or in a manner that is not age-appropriate or developmentally appropriate for students in accordance with state standards.”

Parents can sue districts over violations.